🖤 Define your edge, effortlessly and ethically.
The e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen features a precision felt tip for versatile line control, a waterproof and quick-drying formula that lasts all day, and a vitamin-enriched formula that nourishes lashes. Fully vegan and cruelty-free certified, it delivers bold, jet-black pigment for confident, long-lasting eye definition.
J**D
Long lasting, bold color, easy to apply
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐I have been using this product for about 5 years now, and it remains my absolute favorite eyeliner! The felt tip makes application effortless, allowing for precise, smooth lines every time. It’s intensely pigmented, long-lasting, and truly waterproof—I’ve worn it through rain, workouts, and even long days without any smudging or fading. The formula glides on seamlessly without tugging, and it dries quickly to a beautiful, bold finish. For the price, the quality is unbeatable! If you're looking for an affordable, reliable, and high-performing eyeliner, this is the one. Highly recommend!
T**A
Great product. Definitely recommend.
The fact that this is a FELT TIP makes it SOOOOOOO much easier to apply because I don't have to worry about strings sticking out, ruining my application. Good quality, beautiful look, and with a smooth hand, I can have perfect eyeliner applied. It dries quickly, so no smudging. Easy to apply, if you know what you're doing. And great price! Definitely recommend for someone looking for good quality liquid eyeliner for a reasonable price. I'm very happy and definitely plan on purchasing again in the near future, when I've used it all up. I've found my forever eyeliner!!!
L**J
Long-lasting, dark black, and easy to apply
I love this dang eyeliner! I used to use the classic Stila one for $25, but when I got into college, I couldn't afford that. I went on a limb to try this since it was about a quarter of the price, and I was pleasantly surprised. It lasts long, is a deep black, and goes on so easily.My ONLY complaint is that when it's almost empty/ready to be changed, it starts to leak from the felt tip area. If I open the lid, a big drop of ink is there and then it's SUPER watery upon application, not like it usually applies. I would think this was a one-off, but this has happened with almost all the ones I've bought, and I think I'm on my 9th or 10th at this point. :) Just something to look out for.
E**E
works great
### Review: e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen#### Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)I recently tried the e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen in Jet Black, and while there are several aspects I appreciated, there are also a few drawbacks that are worth noting.#### What I Loved:**1. Bold Pigmentation:**The pigmentation of this eyeliner is truly impressive. The Jet Black shade is deep, rich, and provides a striking, bold look that makes your eyes pop. It delivers a high-impact finish that enhances any makeup style, from everyday wear to more dramatic evening looks.**2. Precise Felt Tip:**The felt tip applicator is another standout feature. It’s perfectly designed for precision, making it easy to create both thin, subtle lines and bold, dramatic wings. Whether you’re a makeup novice or a seasoned pro, this liner allows for controlled, smooth application every time.**3. Vegan & Cruelty-Free:**As a brand, e.l.f. is committed to ethical beauty, and this eyeliner is no exception. It’s 100% vegan and cruelty-free, which is a huge plus for anyone looking to make more conscientious beauty choices without compromising on quality.#### Areas for Improvement:**1. Waterproof Claims:**Despite being marketed as waterproof, I found the H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen to fall short in this area. While it holds up well under light moisture, it doesn’t withstand heavier exposure to water or sweat. This can be disappointing if you’re expecting it to last through a rainy day or an intense workout.**2. Smudging:**One of the main issues I encountered was smudging. Throughout the day, especially during warmer conditions or if my skin becomes oily, the eyeliner tends to smudge and lose its crispness. This can lead to a less polished look by the end of the day, which is less than ideal for those who need their makeup to stay put for extended periods.#### Final Thoughts:The e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen has some fantastic qualities, particularly in terms of pigmentation and ease of application. It’s a great option for creating bold, defined looks with a clean conscience thanks to its vegan and cruelty-free formulation. However, if you’re specifically seeking a truly waterproof and smudge-resistant eyeliner, this might not fully meet your expectations.For those looking for an affordable, highly pigmented liner that is easy to apply, this is a solid choice. Just be prepared for some touch-ups throughout the day if you want to maintain a flawless look.
A**O
Cute! Recommend, and I would buy again! 😋
Stays on for a long time, dries quickly, does really smudge that much, I really like it! Bolder look too I guess? Good for alt makeup or big eyeliner 💕🎼🍰🦇
K**.
Darn Good!
I've been using gel/liquid eyeliners for decades. My recent preferences have been Stila and Lancome liquid eyeliners. Never liked the KVD or Tom Ford.This is precise, very pigmented and stays on until I take it off with double cleanse. Doesn't bleed into wrinkles.This $7 eyeliner is better than anything I've used. Glad there is an option for brown. Hope more colors will become available.
O**X
5 stars but imagine like 4.75
This eyeliner is VERY pigmented--it is literally one of the blackest blacks I own. It doesn't dry too shiny like some brands, but it is also not fully matte either which I LOVE. It doesn't dry out the eyes or make them itchy, which is an issue I have with A LOT of eyeliners. It stays on all day, withstanding sweat (I am a Chef, so I wore this ALL day in a HOT kitchen and it did not budge one bit in my 8hr shifts) The ONLY issue I do have is getting the lines to a point, I like my wings to look like they could be used as a weapon, so for my wingtips I go in with a gel liner since the felt tip on this just cannot get as thin as I want. I can say be careful as it is drying on your lid if you have hooded eyes to avoid that awful eyeliner smudge just after applying. Hard to remove without Micellar water. Love this eyeliner so far.
Trustpilot
3 weeks ago
1 day ago